N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-10 identifies a few general rules – subject to a number of exceptions – which will apply upon the death of the transferor with respect to a real property interest that is the subject of a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed, which was owned by the transferor at death (hereinafter, the “Transfer on Death Property“.)
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-09, and Title Standard 12-15 of the North Dakota State Bar Association’s real property “title standards“, identify that a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed:
until the death of the transferor – providing that such transferor survives the death of all other joint owners.
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-10, and Title Standard 12-15 identify that the designated beneficiary must survive the death of the transferor in order to be entitled to any rights in the Transfer on Death Property identified in a Transfer on Death Deed.
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-12, and Title Standard 12-17 of the North Dakota State Bar Association’s real property “title standards“, identify that any interest received by a beneficiary identified in a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed may be subject to any unpaid claims against the transferor’s estate if such estate is insufficient to satisfy:
providing that any such claims or allowances are the subject of a collection action commenced within 18 months of the date of the transferor’s death.
There is no requirement that the transferor have exclusive ownership of the Transfer on Death Property at the time that the Transfer on Death Deed is executed, since ownership of the Transfer on Death Property at the time of death of the transferor is sufficient.
However, the lack of exclusive ownership of the Transfer on Death Property at the time of execution of the Transfer on Death Deed may be an issue when:
At the time that a joint tenant signs a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed, a joint tenant-transferor would not have the unilateral right to execute a Transfer on Death Deed with any assurance that it would be effective after the death of that joint tenant-transferor.
However, the joint tenant-transferor will acquire sole ownership rights upon the deaths of all of the other joint tenants – unless the joint tenant-transferor fails to survive the other joint tenants.
Therefore, the Transfer on Death Deed would be effective at the death of the joint tenant-transferor only if such transferor survived the deaths of all of the other joint tenants.
The Transfer on Death Property identified in a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed will be transferred to the designated beneficiary identified in the North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed only if the designated beneficiary survives the death of the transferor.
If there is more than one designated beneficiary identified in a Transfer on Death Deed, the Transfer on Death Property will be transferred to those designated beneficiaries who survive the death of the transferor in equal and undivided shares as tenants in common – with no rights of survivorship – unless the Transfer on Death Deed provides otherwise.
Therefore, unless a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed provides to the contrary, if the North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed identifies two or more designated beneficiaries to receive concurrent interests in the Transfer on Death Property upon the death of the transferor, the share of any designated beneficiary which lapses, or fails for any reason:
If a designated beneficiary fails to survive the death of the transferor, the intended transfer of the Transfer on Death Property to such designated beneficiary will lapse and become ineffective – unless the Transfer on Death Deed provides otherwise.
It does not appear that North Dakota’s statutory anti-lapse provisions identified in N.D.C.C. 30.1-09-05:
Therefore, a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed should be written in such a manner that it makes provision for contingent beneficiaries upon the deaths of the primary beneficiaries, if a complete lapse of the intended transfer of the Transfer on Death Property is not an acceptable result.
In addition, a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed should be written in such a manner that minors would not acquire ownership interests in North Dakota real property upon the death of the transferor – due to the legal incapacity of minors to contract for the sale or leasing of such interests.
Minnesota’s Transfer on Death Deed statute specifically makes Minnesota’s antilapse statute identified in M.S. 507.071, Subd. 11 applicable to Minnesota Transfer on Death Deeds, by providing as follows:
Therefore, the consequences of a grantee beneficiary identified in a Minnesota Transfer on Death Deed dying before the transferor are clear.
If a Minnesota grantee beneficiary [which North Dakota refers to as a designated beneficiary] who is:
of the Minnesota grantor owner [which North Dakota refers to as a transferor],
fails to survive the death of the Minnesota grantor owner [which North Dakota refers to as a transferor],
by one hundred twenty hours,
will receive the Transfer on Death Property instead of the deceased grantee beneficiary [which North Dakota refers to as a designated beneficiary], and the gift to the grantee beneficiary will not lapse, unless the Minnesota Transfer on Death Deed provides otherwise.
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-10(2) identifies that any designated beneficiary will receive the Transfer on Death Property upon the death of the transferor subject to all title matters of record, by providing as follows:
Subject to chapter 47-19, [Record Title] a beneficiary takes the property subject to all conveyances, encumbrances, assignments, contracts, mortgages, liens, and other interests to which the property is subject at the transferor’s death.
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-09, and Title Standard 12-15, also identify that the Transfer on Death Property will be subject to prior conveyances, liens, and other interests to which the Transfer on Death Property is subject at the transferor’s death.
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-10(2) identifies the “effective” date of recording a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed for title transfer purposes, by providing in part as follows:
For purposes of this subsection and chapter 47-19 [Record Title], the recording of the transfer on death deed is deemed to have occurred at the transferor’s death.
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-10(3) identifies that the death of a transferor who had executed a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed has no effect on the rights of a surviving joint tenant, by providing in part as follows:
If a transferor is a joint owner and is: . . . Survived by one or more other joint owners, the property that is the subject of a transfer on death deed belongs to the surviving joint owner or owners with right of survivorship;
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-10(3) identifies that a Transfer on Death Deed will be effective upon the death of the last surviving joint tenant transferor, by providing in part as follows:
If a transferor is a joint owner and is: . . . The last surviving joint owner, the transfer on death deed is effective.
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-10(4) identifies that a Transfer on Death Deed:
by providing in part as follows:
A transfer on death deed transfers property without covenant or warranty of title even if the deed contains a contrary provision.
N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-10 generally identifies that the Transfer on Death Property will be transferred to the designated beneficiary if the designated beneficiary survives the death of the transferor.
However, North Dakota‘s version of the Uniform Real Property Transfer on Death Act does not identify any procedures which would provide evidence of the death of the transferor.
N.D.C.C. 47-19-06 does authorize the filing of a certified copy of a death certificate in order to evidence the death of a transferor, by providing in part as follows:
duly certified by any officer who is required by the laws of the state or country in which the record is made, to keep a record of the death of persons occurring within the jurisdiction of the officer,
may be recorded in the office of the recorder of the county in which the lands are situated.
The legal description of any property to which the recording of the death certificate relates must be attached to the death certificate.
N.D.C.C. 47-19-06 also identifies the effect of filing a certified copy of a death certificate to evidence the death of the transferor, by providing in part as follows:
The certified copy of death certificate, . . . is prima facie evidence of the death of the person and the termination of . . . all the estate, title, interest, . . . as was or is limited upon the life of that person.
Therefore, the filing of a copy of the death certificate in the manner identified above:
While N.D.C.C. 47-19-06 will provide record evidence of the death of the transferor, neither that provision, nor North Dakota‘s version of the Uniform Real Property Transfer on Death Act, identifies any procedure to prove that the designated beneficiaries survived the death of the transferor – North Dakota Transfer on Death Deeds – Death of the Transferor.
While N.D.C.C. Section 47-19-06 provides authority for filing a certified copy of a Death Certificate in order to terminate:
it does not specifically authorize the filing of an Affidavit of Survivorship, either separately, or attached to the certified copy of the Death Certificate.
Title Standards 4-05, and 18-01 of the North Dakota State Bar Association’s real property “title standards” identify that the filing of an Affidavit – whether or not attached to a Death Certificate – should be sufficient in order to terminate:
but say nothing about providing evidence of survivorship with respect to North Dakota Transfer on Death Deeds.
Presumably, if the sole surviving designated beneficiary is the Affiant with respect to an Affidavit of Survivorship identifying the death the transferor – the execution, acknowledgment, and recording of the Affidavit of Survivorship should be conclusive evidence of survivorship by the Affiant – designated beneficiary.
However, there does not appear to be any statutory authority for providing evidence in the public title record as to the survival of persons other than the Affiant.
Therefore, North Dakota’s current Transfer on Death Deed statutory provisions may work best when:
However, North Dakota’s Transfer on Death Deed statutes expressly authorize multiple designated beneficiaries.
Nevertheless, since survivorship by the designated beneficiary or designated beneficiaries is a statutory prerequisite to the effective transfer of North Dakota Transfer on Death Property pursuant to a Transfer on Death Deed, North Dakota should perhaps provide a statutory procedure for providing evidence of survivorship – as does Minnesota.
Minnesota’s Transfer on Death Deed statute addresses the survivorship of the grantee beneficiary – which North Dakota refers to as a designated beneficiary – in a more comprehensive manner, and is designed to identify not only:
pursuant to M.S. 507.071, Subd. 20, which provides in part as follows:
In Minnesota, an Affidavit of Identity and Survivorship – which is designed to vest title in the grantee beneficiary – will not be effective unless it is accompanied by a clearance certificate identifying the absence of any claim for the recovery of medical assistance benefits by the State of Minnesota.
North Dakota has no statutory requirement for the recording of an Affidavit of Survivorship, nor a Medical Assistance clearance certificate.
Nevertheless, N.D.C.C. 30.1-32.1-12 identifies that claims against the Transfer on Death Property can be made if the value of the transferor / decedent’s other property is insufficient to pay claims against the transferor / decedent’s estate, or statutory allowances to beneficiaries.
Owners of North Dakota real property interests – including mineral rights – who are contemplating transferring such interests pursuant to a North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed are invited to contact Minnesota and North Dakota attorney Gary C. Dahle for assistance.
Attorneys not licensed in Minnesota or North Dakota are invited to refer possible Minnesota or North Dakota Transfer on Death Deed issues to Minnesota and North Dakota attorney Gary C. Dahle, at 763-780-8390, or [email protected].
Topics of Interest:
Copyright 2016 – All Rights Reserved
Gary C. Dahle – Attorney at Law
2704 Mounds View Blvd., Mounds View, MN 55112
Phone: 763-780-8390 Fax: 763-780-1735 [email protected]
Legal Disclaimer
Information provided herein is only for general informational and educational purposes. North Dakota’s version of the Uniform Real Property Transfer on Death Act involves many complex legal issues. If you have a specific legal problem about which you are seeking advice, consult with a North Dakota attorney of your choice. Gary C. Dahle, Attorney at Law, is licensed to practice law only in the State of North Dakota, and in the State of Minnesota, in the United States of America. Therefore, only those persons interested in matters governed by the laws of the State of North Dakota and Minnesota should consult with, or provide information to, Gary C. Dahle, Attorney at Law, or take note of information provided herein.
Accessing the web sites of Gary C. Dahle, Attorney at Law – http://www.dahlelaw.com, https://northdakotatransferondeathdeeds.com, or http://www.dahlelawnorthdakota.com – may be held to be requests for information. However, the mere act of either providing information to Gary C. Dahle, Attorney at Law, or taking note of information provided on http://www.dahlelaw.com, https://northdakotatransferondeathdeeds.com, or http://www.dahlelawnorthdakota.com – does not constitute legal advice, or establish an attorney/client relationship.
Nothing herein will be deemed to be the practice of law or the provision of legal advice. Clients are accepted by Gary C. Dahle, Attorney at Law, only after preliminary personal communications with him, and subject to mutual agreement on terms of representation. If you are not a current client of Gary C. Dahle, Attorney at Law, please do not use the e-mail links or forms to communicate confidential information which you wish to be protected by the attorney-client privilege.
